The Hat Which Makes The Magic I

It’s a cold morning when Star appears on your farm with very little warning. There is a distinct lack of feathers, and that strikes you as a little odd.

“Have you seen these witch hats? Everyone’s talking about them, and I want some. Are they better than wizard hats? Well, that’s a ludicrous idea, but maybe it’s worth checking some of them out anyways. Could you bring me some to study?”